Scientists are learning more about nicotinamide riboside vs NAD+ as these vital compounds affect our cellular health. NAD+ levels drop by 10% to 65% as we age, and this varies by organ. This decline leads to health problems like cognitive issues and metabolic disorders, which makes people think about ways to keep their NAD+ at good levels.
Your body needs NAD+ to work properly. It helps with over 500 enzyme reactions that control metabolism, immunity, sleep cycles, and muscle performance. On top of that, it powers energy production, keeps cells healthy, repairs DNA, and activates sirtuins - proteins that control key cellular processes. NAD+ supplements offer a direct solution, but nicotinamide riboside has become popular because it works well as an NAD+ precursor. Research shows that NR supplements can increase NAD+ levels in mammalian cells by up to 270%. This high number comes from NR's ability to enter cells easily.
Finding the best NAD+ supplement isn't easy. Research shows nicotinamide riboside supplements safely boost NAD+ levels in middle-aged and older adults. NR works better than NMN (another common precursor) at increasing NAD+ levels because cells absorb it more efficiently. Scientists keep studying these compounds, giving people who want to age healthily several options to think about.
Nicotinamide Riboside vs NAD+: Key Differences Explained
The fundamental molecular makeup and bodily interactions help us understand the key differences between nicotinamide riboside and NAD+.
Molecular structure and function
Nicotinamide riboside (NR) has a pyridine-nucleoside structure and belongs to the vitamin B3 family [1]. NR works as a precursor to nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+), rather than being NAD+ itself. NAD+'s molecular structure is more complex by a lot compared to NR, with an extra adenine nucleotide and phosphate group.
These compounds follow a clear pathway in their relationship. Cells absorb NR, which nicotinamide riboside kinase enzymes (NRK1 and NRK2) phosphorylate to create nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN) [1]. NMN-adenylyltransferase (NMNAT) then transforms NMN into NAD+ [1]. This multi-step process makes NR a "precursor" rather than a direct form of NAD+.
NAD+ plays a vital role as a coenzyme for redox reactions, making it essential for energy metabolism [2]. NAD+ also acts as a required cofactor for non-redox NAD+-dependent enzymes, especially sirtuins and poly(ADP-ribose) polymerases (PARPs) [2]. These enzymes are the foundations of cellular health maintenance, DNA repair, and aging processes.
Direct vs indirect supplementation
The main difference between these compounds lies in how they supplement the body. NAD+ supplementation tries to deliver the complete molecule directly, while NR supplementation provides a precursor that becomes NAD+.
Direct NAD+ supplementation faces major hurdles. NAD+ struggles with absorption through the digestive system and can't easily cross cell membranes [3]. This limitation reduces its effectiveness in oral form. People often need alternative methods like intravenous administration to get around these digestive issues.
NR supplementation takes an indirect approach that works better. NR enters cells easily through specific transporters before becoming NAD+ [3]. This indirect pathway offers several benefits as NR can:
-
Cross cell membranes efficiently
-
Utilize established metabolic pathways for conversion
-
Bypass rate-limiting steps in other NAD+ synthesis routes
-
Avoid undesirable side effects associated with other precursors
Research shows that NR supplementation boosts NAD+ levels in multiple tissues, lifts sirtuin activity, and improves mitochondrial function [4]. NR ends up being a more practical solution to boost cellular NAD+ despite taking an indirect route.
Which is more bioavailable?
Bioavailability measures how well a substance reaches its target in active form, and NR clearly outperforms direct NAD+ supplementation. A single oral dose of NR can boost human blood NAD+ levels up to 2.7-fold [5]. Mouse studies show NR increases hepatic NAD+ better than nicotinic acid and nicotinamide [5].
NR creates larger increases in NAD+ metabolism compared to nicotinamide (NAM) or nicotinic acid (NA), with unique kinetics that make it particularly effective [5]. NR gets more NAD+ and NADP+ than similar doses of NAM, and produces three times more ADPR buildup—showing greater NAD+-consuming activities [5].
Studies demonstrate how NR supplementation reliably increases NAD+ levels across various tissues:
-
Liver and skeletal muscles showed significant NAD+ increases
-
Brown adipose tissue responded positively to NR
-
Blood measurements showed dose-dependent increases with NR
Tissues with lower NRK enzyme expression, like brain and white adipose tissue, showed smaller changes [4]. This variation relates to tissue-specific expression of NRK1 (found everywhere) and NRK2 (mainly in cardiac and skeletal muscles) [4].
Clinical research confirms that 1000 mg NR doses twice daily can boost steady-state, whole-blood NAD+ levels up to 2.7-fold after one dose [4]. Studies also show NR increases NAD+ levels based on dose size, with 100, 300, and 1000 mg doses raising NAD+ by about 22%, 51%, and 142% within two weeks [6].
The structural differences between these compounds create practical variations in how they deliver benefits, even though both support NAD+ metabolism.
How Each Affects Energy and Aging
Both NAD+ and nicotinamide riboside play significant roles in energy metabolism and aging processes, though they work differently. Scientists are fascinated by how these compounds affect longevity and vitality through various cellular pathways.
NAD+ in ATP production and redox balance
NAD+ serves as a vital cofactor in energy metabolism. This compound carries electrons in over 500 enzymatic reactions that extract energy from nutrients. NAD+ accepts electrons and hydrogen atoms to become NADH during several key processes:
- Glycolysis, where each glucose molecule generates 2 molecules of NADH [7]
- The tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle, which converts 4 molecules of NAD+ to NADH using one molecule of pyruvate [8]
- Fatty acid β-oxidation, where NAD+ helps break down fats for energy [8]
- Mitochondrial electron transport chain, where NADH donates electrons to produce ATP [9]
The cell's energy status is reflected in its NAD+/NADH ratio. Cytoplasmic ratios typically stay at 1000:1 while mitochondrial ratios remain closer to 10:1 [10]. This balance regulates metabolism by influencing glycolysis rates and pyruvate flow to mitochondria [8]. Age-related imbalances in this ratio reduce mitochondrial function, which leads to lower ATP production and more reactive oxygen species (ROS) [8].
The rate of energy production depends on NAD+'s availability in the cytoplasm. Cell death can occur if cytoplasmic NAD+ is eliminated because this blocks glycolysis [8]. NAD+ also helps produce NADP+ through NAD+ kinases, which helps maintain cellular redox balance and remove ROS [10].
NR's role in boosting NAD+ for longevity
NR has emerged as a powerful NAD+ precursor that could slow aging. Unlike direct NAD+ supplements, NR easily crosses cell membranes and converts to NAD+ through the body's natural pathways.
Research shows that taking NR orally increases NAD+ levels in liver, skeletal muscle, and brain tissue [4]. This boost in NAD+ helps counter its natural decline with age - a major factor in age-related conditions [1].
NR's ability to restore NAD+ levels addresses many aging markers. Animal studies show that NR supplements improved mitochondrial function, boosted stem cell regeneration, and helped animals live longer [11]. These benefits match those seen with calorie restriction, which helps extend lifespan across various species [6].
Patients with Parkinson's disease who took 1000 mg of NR daily showed higher brain NAD+ levels and less brain inflammation [12]. Heart studies revealed that NR helped balance the heart's NAD+/NADH ratio and protected against harmful cardiac changes [13]. This suggests NR might help organs function better as we age.
Impact on sirtuins and cellular repair
NAD+, NR, and aging are connected through sirtuin activation. Sirtuins need NAD+ to work properly and regulate many aging-related processes [7]. As we age and NAD+ levels drop, sirtuins become less active, which speeds up aging [10].
Sirtuins affect aging in multiple ways. SIRT1 and SIRT6 modify histones, which changes how genes are expressed [10]. SIRT1 also modifies proteins like p53 and NF-κB, which affect inflammation and DNA repair pathways [10]. SIRT6 helps maintain stable telomeres, which directly influences how cells age [10].
Taking NR activates sirtuins by increasing NAD+ levels. This activation helps cells resist oxidative stress by changing how FOXO1 works [14]. NR specifically increases important antioxidant genes like catalase, SOD1, and SOD2 [14].
NAD+ also helps repair DNA damage. Low NAD+ levels can hurt DNA repair, especially through reduced PARP1 function [15]. DNA damage activates PARP1, which quickly uses up NAD+, creating a harmful cycle. NR supplements show promise in easing this burden and helping repair DNA in neurodegenerative disease models [15].
For practical use in supporting energy metabolism and curbing age-related decline, NR works better than direct NAD+ supplements.
Scientific Evidence and Clinical Trials
Clinical research exploring NAD+ precursors and direct NAD+ supplementation has grown faster in the last several years. Scientists have conducted many trials to study their effects on human health and aging.
NR human trials: NAD+ level increases
Clinical trials have consistently showed that nicotinamide riboside raises NAD+ levels in humans effectively. A key randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover trial revealed that NR supplementation (1000 mg daily) for 6 weeks increased blood cellular NAD+ concentrations by approximately 60% compared to placebo [4]. People with naturally lower blood NAD+ levels responded better to supplementation [4].
Scientists have proven NR's effectiveness through multiple dose-finding studies. One trial with 140 middle-aged volunteers showed dose-dependent increases in whole blood NAD+ levels after 8 weeks. Daily doses of 100 mg increased NAD+ by about 10%, 300 mg by 48%, and 1000 mg by 139% [16]. The first human studies showed that even single NR doses could increase NAD+ metabolites in peripheral blood mononuclear cells [3].
Brain research has produced exciting results lately. A newer study, published in 2023, showed that acute NR supplementation (900 mg) raised mean cerebral NAD+ concentration from 0.392 mM to 0.458 mM—about 16% higher than baseline [17]. This data proves that NR supplementation directly affects brain NAD+ metabolism.
NAD+ IV therapy: What the data says
IV NAD+ administration offers a different way to boost NAD+ levels by skipping initial digestive processing. Research shows that NAD+ administration at 3 μmoles/min substantially increased plasma NAD+ levels by 398% after 6 hours of infusion [18]. The patient's urinary NAD+ excretion also jumped by 538% [18].
NAD+ IV therapy comes with its challenges. Scientists made an unexpected discovery: standard infusion rates cause NAD+ to disappear from plasma faster during the first 2 hours. This suggests extracellular metabolism happens before cellular uptake [18].
Cognitive performance research suggests that IV NAD+ might enhance various cognitive functions beyond typical practice effects [19]. To cite an instance, a small controlled study of NAD+ infusions (750 mg/day for 5 days) showed substantial improvements in 6 out of 8 cognitive tests [19].
Comparative studies on efficacy
Head-to-head comparisons between NR and NAD+ supplementation remain rare. A recent randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled pilot study compared intravenous NR (500 mg), NAD+ (500 mg), oral NR (500 mg), and saline placebo [5]. NR IV showed better tolerability than NAD+ IV, with a 75% shorter mean infusion time [5]. NR IV also created stronger increases in blood NAD+ concentration. Peak levels rose by 20.7% compared to baseline—performing better than both NAD+ IV and oral NR at the 3-hour mark [5].
Evidence for specific clinical applications continues to emerge. A double-blind randomized trial with 90 peripheral artery disease patients showed NR improved 6-minute walk distance by 17.6 meters after 6 months compared to placebo [20]. Yet not all results paint a positive picture. The NAD+ metabolites increased in 40 sedentary obese men who took NR supplements (2000 mg daily) for 12 weeks. However, their body composition and insulin sensitivity remained unchanged [3].
Current evidence confirms that NR supplementation reliably increases NAD+ levels in tissues of all types. IV NAD+ shows potential but faces bioavailability challenges that researchers continue to explore.
Use Cases: Who Should Take What?
Your choice between nicotinamide riboside and NAD+ supplementation should match your health goals and personal situation. Research shows different groups might benefit more from one option over the other.
Athletes and energy seekers
Research about NAD+ supplementation for athletic performance shows varied results. Animal studies reveal NR supplementation helped mice run longer distances and boost exercise capacity [21]. Human studies paint a different picture. Athletes who took NMN supplements at 300, 600, and 1200 mg/day while training for endurance saw small improvements in aerobic performance over 6 weeks [21].
Studies of older mice showed NR boosted endurance capacity by 56-80% and improved hindlimb grip strength after 6 weeks [22]. NR helps ATP production in mitochondria, which gives you more energy during intense workouts [23].
Athletes who want quick results might prefer direct NAD+ supplementation through IV. NR works better as a long-term solution to support NAD+ metabolism throughout training periods.
Older adults and anti-aging goals
NR shows remarkable potential for age-related issues. Studies prove that NR can boost NAD+ levels in older adults. This helps counter the 10-80% drop in NAD+ that happens as we age [16].
NR supplementation at 1000 mg daily helped Parkinson's patients by increasing their brain NAD+ levels and reducing brain inflammation [16]. Heart health research shows NR balanced the myocardial NAD+/NADH ratio and protected against harmful cardiac changes [24].
NR activates sirtuins by increasing NAD+ availability. This might help cells resist oxidative stress better [24].
People with metabolic or cognitive concerns
Research suggests promising results for people with metabolic issues who take NR. Prediabetic women who took 250 mg/day of NMN for 10 weeks substantially improved their insulin sensitivity [21]. Animal studies also show NR helps improve glucose tolerance and protects against insulin resistance [24].
NAD+ administration helped fix cognitive problems and reduced brain inflammation in animal studies [25]. Older adults with mild cognitive impairment took NR for 8 weeks and showed lower pTau217 levels - a key marker for Alzheimer's disease [26].
People with high blood pressure saw impressive results too. NR supplements lowered systolic readings by nearly 10 mmHg in those with above-normal baseline readings. These results match the effectiveness of major blood pressure medications [4].
Supplement Quality, Forms, and Brands
The quality and delivery method of NAD+ supplements play a big role in how well they work. You'll find many options in the market that differ a lot in their strength and reliability.
Top NR supplements: Niagen and others
Niagen leads the way as the standard for nicotinamide riboside supplements. Over 35 clinical studies back this patented form of NR that showed it's safe and works well to raise NAD+ levels [27]. NSF Certified for Sport and Alkemist Assured test and verify its quality [2].
Thorne NiaCel stands out with its exclusive NR form and NSF Certification for Sport [28]. A Harvard-trained physician created Wonderfeel Youngr NMN, backed by more than 15,000 peer-reviewed papers [29]. Life Extension gives you budget-friendly NAD+ precursor options like their Cell Regenerator with nicotinamide riboside [29].
NAD+ IV vs oral NAD+ vs liposomal
NAD+ IV therapy puts the molecule straight into your bloodstream without digestive barriers. The nutrients start working right away [30]. But studies show your body removes NAD+ faster from plasma in the first 2 hours after infusion.
Oral NAD+ supplements usually contain components that your body turns into NAD+. These include vitamin B3, Nicotinamide Riboside, and Nicotinamide Mononucleotide [30]. These supplements are easy to take but must go through digestion, which reduces how much your body absorbs.
Liposomal delivery wraps ingredients in lipid layers to help absorption. But here's the catch - NAD+ precursors like NR break down quickly in water and "degrade rapidly within weeks" [2]. Lab tests found that many liposomal products had nowhere near the NR amount they claimed [31].
How to review supplement quality
Look for third-party testing credentials first. The best supplements get thorough verification from groups like NSF Certified for Sport [2]. Next, check analysis certificates - companies like Tru Niagen let you verify lot numbers online [31].
Watch out for certain product forms. Tests showed many gummies and liposomal products had either no NR or just 2.2% of what they claimed [31]. Buy only from authorized sellers to avoid fakes, especially on marketplace platforms [31].
Cost, Accessibility, and Legal Status
The best NAD+ supplementation method depends not just on how well it works. Cost and regulatory status play a crucial role in making the right choice.
Price comparison: NR vs NAD+
These options come with very different price tags. A month's supply of oral NAD+ supplements costs between £23.82 and £79.42 [8]. The injectable NAD+ treatments are much more expensive at £119.12 to £397.08 per session [8]. The higher cost comes from the need for clinical administration.
The cost per gram shows big differences among NAD+ precursors:
-
Renue By Science sublingual powder: £0.79 per gram [9]
-
ProHealth Longevity NMN Pro: £1.52 per gram [9]
-
Thorne NiaCel: £2.17 per gram [9]
-
Tru Niagen: £4.15 per gram [9]
-
Elysium Basis: £6.35 per gram [9]
You can save money with subscription models. Elysium Health's NR supplement costs £31.77 per bottle with yearly subscriptions, compared to £47.65 for one-time purchases [32].
Availability in different countries
Product availability varies across the globe. Elysium's Basis can be found in both the United States and Canada [32]. Some formulations are only available in specific regions. Shipping rules and import regulations for these supplements differ from country to country, which affects who can buy them.
FDA status and supplement regulations
The FDA hasn't approved NAD+ or NR as standalone treatments [6]. These products fall under dietary supplement rules set by the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA) [6].
NMN, another NAD+ precursor, faced FDA restrictions in 2022 [11]. Nicotinamide riboside keeps its supplement status. The FDA sees NR as "generally safe to use" [11]. This gives both consumers and manufacturers more confidence.
The rules changed for NMN because pharmaceutical companies started studying it as a potential drug. This led the FDA to remove its dietary supplement status [33]. Legal action by the National Products Association has put a temporary hold on NMN product enforcement as of 2024 [11].
Comparison Table
|
Characteristic |
Nicotinamide Riboside (NR) |
NAD+ |
|---|---|---|
|
Molecular Structure |
Simpler; pyridine-nucleoside form of vitamin B3 |
More complex; contains additional adenine nucleotide and phosphate group |
|
Cell Membrane Penetration |
Crosses cell membranes quickly |
Poor cell membrane penetration |
|
Bioavailability |
High; can increase NAD+ levels up to 270% |
Poor absorption through digestive system |
|
Main Delivery Methods |
Oral supplements |
IV therapy |
|
Blood NAD+ Increase |
Up to 2.7-fold increase with single oral dose |
398% increase with 6-hour IV infusion |
|
Monthly Cost Range |
£23.82 - £79.42 (oral supplements) |
£119.12 - £397.08 (per IV session) |
|
FDA Status |
Recognized as safe for use |
No FDA approval as treatment |
|
Main Mechanism |
Converts to NAD+ through enzymatic pathways |
Direct supplementation |
|
Core Benefits |
- Increases NAD+ levels in multiple tissues |
- Immediate blood level increase |
|
Side Effects |
Well-tolerated |
Rapid plasma removal during first 2 hours of infusion |
Conclusion
The showdown between nicotinamide riboside and NAD+ shows clear strengths and weaknesses on both sides. NR proves more effective and bioavailable than direct NAD+ supplements based on detailed research. Science backs this up - NR passes through cell membranes, turns into NAD+ through natural pathways, and boosts NAD+ levels across tissues, including the brain.
People looking for anti-aging benefits need to think over a few things before choosing. NR's simple molecular structure helps it get into cells better than the complex NAD+ molecules. The way you take it matters too. NR comes in convenient pill form while NAD+ needs IV treatment because your digestive system can't absorb it well.
Clinical trials leave no doubt about NR's effectiveness. It raises NAD+ levels based on dosage and improves various health markers. IV NAD+ therapy makes plasma levels jump faster, but these spikes don't last long as your body breaks it down before cells can use it. NR costs nowhere near as much as regular NAD+ infusions for long-term use.
Your health goals should guide your choice between these supplements. Athletes might benefit from either one depending on their timing needs. Older adults who care about brain function and metabolism usually find NR works better for everyday use. Quality matters a lot - third-party testing shows big differences between what's on the label and what's inside many products.
NAD+ research moves forward at lightning speed with new forms and delivery methods in development. Both supplements help fight age-related NAD+ decline. Right now, NR offers the most practical solution to boost cellular energy, repair DNA, and support healthy aging by improving NAD+ metabolism.
FAQs
Q1. What is the main difference between nicotinamide riboside and NAD+? Nicotinamide riboside (NR) is a precursor that the body converts into NAD+, while NAD+ is the final form used in cellular processes. NR is more easily absorbed by cells and effectively raises NAD+ levels, whereas direct NAD+ supplementation faces absorption challenges.
Q2. How do NR and NAD+ supplements affect energy levels and aging? Both NR and NAD+ support energy production and combat aging by increasing cellular NAD+ levels. This boost activates sirtuins, enzymes involved in cellular repair and longevity. NR has shown particular promise in improving mitochondrial function and enhancing cellular resistance to oxidative stress.
Q3. Which supplement is more effective for raising NAD+ levels in the body? Research indicates that nicotinamide riboside (NR) is generally more effective at raising NAD+ levels in the body. NR can increase blood NAD+ concentrations by up to 2.7-fold after a single dose, while being more easily absorbed and utilized by cells compared to direct NAD+ supplementation.
Q4. Are there any side effects associated with NR or NAD+ supplementation? Nicotinamide riboside is generally well-tolerated with few reported side effects. NAD+ supplementation, especially when administered intravenously, may cause rapid plasma removal during the first few hours of infusion. As with any supplement, it's advisable to consult with a healthcare professional before starting either.
Q5. How do the costs of NR and NAD+ supplements compare? NR supplements are typically more affordable for long-term use, with monthly costs ranging from about £24 to £80 for oral supplements. NAD+ therapy, often administered intravenously, is considerably more expensive, with sessions costing between £120 to £400 each. The higher cost of NAD+ therapy is largely due to the clinical administration requirements.
References
[1] - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2212877821000351
[2] - https://www.truniagen.com/blogs/tru-niagen-labs/the-harsh-reality-of-nr-supplements-whats-in-your-supplements
[3] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10361580/
[4] - https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-03421-7
[5] - https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.06.06.24308565v1
[6] - https://omre.co/blogs/news/is-nad-fda-approved-regulatory-status-explained?srsltid=AfmBOooU60qwxh0KL5JtsXHCOsXTppBB5ujuLismg82Ln2dACwl2L1YH
[7] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7963035/
[8] - https://omre.co/blogs/news/how-much-does-nad-cost-price-comparison-guide?srsltid=AfmBOopUPFYGcsYAtDombRqty2kOysWybXqpsEMnN1Gjw2q2oPvXYEeH
[9] - https://www.innerbody.com/best-nad-supplement
[10] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9194868/
[11] - https://www.forbes.com/health/supplements/nicotinamide-mononucleotide/
[12] - https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.adi4862
[13] - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27489254/
[14] - https://www.cell.com/fulltext/S1550-4131(12)00192-1
[15] - https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-57506-9
[16] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10692436/
[17] - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39044608/
[18] - https://nadresearch.org/measuring-nad-metabolome-during-intravenous-infusion/
[19] - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0003999321011096
[20] - https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-49092-5
[21] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9734213/
[22] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8204261/
[23] - https://www.jinfiniti.com/nad-athletic-performance/?srsltid=AfmBOopfhCfoUIUmhyruGgVSGUf8nf_XqU7FfAyyi0BrzBNB8V-4VP7D
[24] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7352172/
[25] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8444613/
[26] - https://alz-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/trc2.70023
[27] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6611812/
[28] - https://www.vogue.com/article/best-nad-supplements
[29] - https://www.thegoodtrade.com/features/nad-supplements/
[30] - https://hydrationroom.com/blog/nad-oral-vs-iv-exploring-the-best-delivery-method-for-your-needs
[31] - https://www.truniagen.com/blogs/tru-niagen-labs/the-harsh-reality-of-nr-supplements-whats-in-your-supplements?srsltid=AfmBOord6yL1vhnVDXi4rfd0lWW3k7sxg1Uza8Tc7sDhvtF6sDfS-tNp
[32] - https://www.elysiumhealth.com/products/basis?srsltid=AfmBOoqCUajBXWcPGyIR06dp2SPV6VfM1XJ95zm3wNxnMl0ugb2Jfqyp
[33] - https://www.nmn.com/news/fda-bans-labeling-nmn-as-a-supplement
