Ashwagandha vs Fenugreek: Best Herb for Testosterone Over 60?

by Goldman Labs Team

The latest research shows amazing results when comparing ashwagandha and fenugreek testosterone benefits. A 20-year study revealed men with the lowest testosterone levels have a 40% higher risk of death compared to those with higher levels . These numbers highlight why natural testosterone support has become crucial for men as they age.

Studies show both herbs can help boost testosterone levels naturally. Clinical research found ashwagandha supplements increased testosterone 14.7% more than placebo . Fenugreek has shown similar hormone-boosting abilities. A complete review confirmed that both ashwagandha root and fenugreek seed extracts help increase testosterone levels in men . Anyone looking to use natural testosterone herbs should know how these adaptogens work and which one works better.

This piece dives into the science behind these two popular natural testosterone boosters and what they mean for men over 60. You'll learn about how they work, what research says, and practical tips to help you pick the right herb for your testosterone needs.

Understanding Testosterone Decline After 60

Men's testosterone production changes a lot after age 60. These changes affect their health and well-being. Learning about this natural process helps us evaluate potential solutions, including herbal alternatives like ashwagandha and fenugreek.

How testosterone levels change with age

Most men's testosterone peaks around age 17 and stays high for 20-30 years ^[1]. Production starts dropping around age 30-40, falling about 1% each year ^[2]. Free and bioavailable testosterone—the forms that matter most for biological function—drop even faster at 2-3% yearly ^[2].

The decline speeds up after 60. Studies show 20% of men over 60 have total testosterone below normal levels ^[2]. The numbers look worse for older men - half of those over 80 have low testosterone ^[2]. The Massachusetts Male Aging Study found that one-third of men over 45 might have lower than normal testosterone levels ^[3].

Each man's testosterone levels are different. Normal levels range from 270 to 1,070 nanograms per deciliter (ng/dL) ^[1]. Healthy men in their 40s usually have total testosterone between 252-916 ng/dL, while levels in their 70s often fall between 156-819 ng/dL ^[1]. These wide ranges explain why some men have more noticeable symptoms than others.

Symptoms of low testosterone in older men

Low testosterone in men over 60, also called late-onset hypogonadism (LOH), shows up through physical, emotional, and sexual symptoms. Early detection of these signs leads to better treatment:

Sexual changes: Lower sex drive and desire ^[4], erectile dysfunction ^[5], and less sexual satisfaction ^[4]
Physical changes: Muscle loss ^[4], more belly fat ^[4], weaker bones ^[4], less energy and tiredness ^[4], and body hair loss ^[5]
Cognitive/emotional changes: Mood swings and irritability ^[2], depression ^[2], poor focus ^[5], and short-term memory problems ^[2]

These changes often happen slowly, making them easy to brush off as "normal aging." In spite of that, multiple symptoms occurring together need medical attention. While only 10% to 25% of older men have clinically low testosterone ^[5], it can affect their quality of life deeply.

Why natural testosterone herbs are gaining popularity

Sales of herbal products keep growing, reaching $6.99 billion in the US in 2018 ^[6]. Several reasons explain this trend.

Testosterone replacement therapy (TRT) works but has major limits. The FDA approves TRT only for "classic" or permanent androgen deficiency, not age-related decline ^[6]. Men with prostate disease, high hematocrit, heart disease risk, or sleep apnea might not qualify for TRT ^[6].

Natural approaches seem safer with fewer side effects. Many herbs have worked in traditional medicine for centuries ^[6]. New research on herbs like ashwagandha vs fenugreek to boost testosterone has made these natural options more appealing.

Lifestyle choices play a big role in testosterone levels. Overweight men have more problems with low testosterone—30% compared to 6.4% in men with normal weight ^[5]. About 24.5% of diabetic men have low testosterone versus 12.6% of men without diabetes ^[5]. The link to diet and lifestyle—especially the Mediterranean diet and supplements like [boron](https://goldmanlaboratories.com/blogs/blog/boron-testosterone)—makes natural solutions attractive.

Ashwagandha: Mechanism and Benefits

Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera) — traditional herbal supplement used for stress, vitality, and hormonal support.

Ashwagandha sets itself apart from other natural testosterone herbs through its unique two-way approach to hormone optimization. This ancient adaptogenic herb doesn't directly stimulate hormones. Instead, it works through complex biological pathways that support testosterone production naturally and effectively.

How ashwagandha affects cortisol and testosterone

The way ashwagandha boosts testosterone mainly comes from its ability to lower cortisol. Research shows high cortisol can suppress testosterone - creating a hormonal see-saw effect. Clinical studies found that ashwagandha supplements reduced cortisol levels by up to 30% in people dealing with chronic stress ^[7]. This substantial drop creates better conditions for testosterone to thrive.

The herb targets the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, which controls stress response and hormone production ^[1]. By balancing this vital pathway, ashwagandha helps normalize adrenal function and boosts the entire endocrine system's performance ^[1].

The herb contains compounds called withanolides that look structurally similar to testosterone, which might explain its hormone-boosting effects ^[8].

Adaptogen comparison: stress and hormone balance

Ashwagandha helps your body fight off physical, chemical, and biological stressors ^[9]. This matters a lot for men over 60 since aging itself acts as a physical stressor that can drain testosterone reserves.

The herb does more than just manage stress. Studies show it increases luteinizing hormone (LH) and follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) in men ^[1] - two pituitary hormones you need to make testosterone. This multi-pathway approach makes ashwagandha different from other adaptogens that only handle stress without touching reproductive hormones.

Older men benefit greatly from these stress-fighting properties. As we age, cortisol tends to rise while testosterone falls - creating a tricky hormone balance that ashwagandha helps fix.

Clinical trials showing testosterone increase

The science backing ashwagandha's testosterone-boosting power is solid. A 16-week study of men aged 40-70 showed ashwagandha supplements led to a 14.7% bigger boost in testosterone compared to placebo ^[10]. The same research found an impressive 18% greater increase in DHEA-S, another key hormone that helps make testosterone ^[10].

Other key findings include:

Men taking ashwagandha root extract saw 17% higher testosterone levels ^[8]
300mg twice daily resulted in much higher testosterone levels than placebo groups ^[4]
Better sperm quality and fertility, with 8 out of 60 partners getting pregnant during a three-month study ^[4]

Higher doses seem to work better, though even moderate amounts show good results.

Impact on sleep, mood, and vitality

Ashwagandha offers more benefits beyond hormone support. Studies show it makes sleep much better - one found 72% improvement versus just 29% in the placebo group after six weeks ^[11]. Better sleep helps make more testosterone, adding another way the herb helps with hormones.

The herb cuts anxiety scores by more than half ^[12] and works as well as common anxiety medications without side effects ^[12]. Better mood relates to greater sexual satisfaction and desire for both men and women ^[12].

Older men looking for more energy will find that ashwagandha helps build muscle strength, speeds up exercise recovery, and improves oxygen use during physical activity ^[13]. This creates a positive cycle - more energy leads to more activity, which supports healthy testosterone levels.

Fenugreek: Mechanism and Benefits

Diagram illustrating diosgenin's effects on glucose absorption, insulin secretion, and glucose metabolism in organs and tissues.

Unlike ashwagandha which reduces stress, fenugreek boosts testosterone production through direct mechanisms. This makes it a powerful natural hormone supporter for aging men.

How fenugreek boosts testosterone directly

Fenugreek works by blocking key enzymes that lower testosterone levels. Studies show that it stops both 5-alpha-reductase and aromatase ^[14]. These two enzymes turn testosterone into dihydrotestosterone (DHT) and estrogen. By blocking these pathways, fenugreek keeps testosterone in its active form.

Research proves that taking fenugreek increases both total and free testosterone levels. One notable study showed that fenugreek extract raised serum total testosterone levels in men ^[15]. This benefit helps older men who face age-related testosterone decline.

The glycoside-rich parts of fenugreek seeds contain sapogenins and saponins that show strong anabolic and androgenic activity ^[6]. These compounds don't just change hormone levels - they help improve muscle performance and body composition. These benefits are vital for men over 60 who lose muscle mass.

Role of diosgenin in hormone synthesis

Diosgenin is the key compound behind fenugreek's testosterone-boosting power. This natural steroidal sapogenin helps create various sex hormones ^[16]. It's the foundation of fenugreek's hormonal benefits.

Diosgenin looks similar to human hormones, especially progesterone, and affects many body processes ^[17]. Companies extract it from wild yams and fenugreek to make steroid hormones like cortisone, estrogen, and testosterone ^[17].

Diosgenin does more than just help make hormones. Here's what else it does:

Helps cells absorb glucose and respond better to insulin ^[18]
Increases muscle growth and improves weight in animal studies ^[16]
Protects pancreatic islet beta cells ^[2]
Lowers inflammation in fat tissue ^[16]

Older men find diosgenin helpful because it supports testosterone production without causing big hormone swings that might lead to side effects.

Clinical evidence from human trials

Several human clinical trials confirm fenugreek's testosterone-boosting effects. A review of four trials found that fenugreek extract substantially increased total serum testosterone in men ^[15].

Men who took 600 mg of fenugreek extract daily saw their testosterone levels rise from where they started ^[6]. Another study showed that during eight weeks of resistance training, people taking Fenu-FG had higher free testosterone levels without losing total testosterone ^[14].

Older men with low testosterone saw their free testosterone levels rise after taking fenugreek extracts. The supplement also reduced physical symptoms of low testosterone ^[6]. This dual action helps address both hormonal changes and symptoms that come with age.

Other metabolic benefits of fenugreek

Fenugreek does more than affect testosterone - it offers complete metabolic benefits too. Studies show it helps control blood sugar levels, which matters because diabetes and insulin resistance link to lower testosterone ^[18].

Fenugreek contains plenty of amino acids, with lysine quality matching soybeans ^[2]. These amino acids help build protein, which men over 60 need to keep their muscle mass.

Taking fenugreek also helps heart health by controlling cholesterol ^[2]. Better cardiovascular health supports hormone balance, as these systems work together closely.

Looking at ashwagandha vs fenugreek testosterone effects, fenugreek stands out because it directly affects hormones while offering other health benefits that help aging men.

Comparing Ashwagandha vs Fenugreek for Testosterone

Side-by-side comparison of ashwagandha and fenugreek, showing ashwagandha roots, leaves, and powder on the left, and fresh fenugreek leaves with fenugreek seeds in a wooden scoop on the right.

Men looking for natural testosterone support often ask about ashwagandha and fenugreek. These powerful botanical supplements support hormone health through different pathways, and their results vary across different measures.

Which has stronger clinical evidence?

Both herbs have got substantial research attention. A systematic review by Smith et al. showed that fenugreek and ashwagandha positively affect testosterone concentrations in men ^[19]. A closer look at the evidence reveals some key differences.

Research shows ashwagandha consistently raises testosterone by 10-22% in randomized controlled trials ^[5]. One notable study saw testosterone levels jump from 630.5 to 726.6 ng/dl - a significant improvement ^[19]. Another study found total testosterone went up from 472.9 to 526.9 ng/dl after supplementation ^[19].

Fenugreek's research tells a different story. Four out of six clinical studies showed higher testosterone concentrations ^[20], with improvements from 12% ^[5] to as high as 46% in some specialized extracts ^[5]. Yes, it is worth noting that a 12-week study showed total testosterone went up from 12.3 to 13.8 nmol/L ^[19].

Two fenugreek studies showed no change in free testosterone levels ^[5], which makes it less reliable than ashwagandha's results. Some supplement manufacturers have sponsored fenugreek research, which might introduce bias ^[5].

Differences in how they work

These herbs boost testosterone through different mechanisms. Ashwagandha works as a stress reducer first, which lowers cortisol levels that can suppress testosterone production. This adaptogenic herb affects the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis, which creates better hormone conditions indirectly ^[21].

Fenugreek takes a more direct approach. Its active compounds—especially diosgenin—block aromatase and 5-alpha reductase ^[19]. These enzymes usually convert testosterone to estrogen and DHT. By stopping these conversion pathways, fenugreek helps preserve existing testosterone instead of making more ^[22].

This difference creates real-world implications. Ashwagandha tackles the root causes like chronic stress that often lead to age-related testosterone decline. Fenugreek targets testosterone metabolism directly, which might give faster results.

Effectiveness in men over 60

Age matters when choosing between these supplements. Studies show ashwagandha works well in men aged 40-70, with a 14.7% better testosterone boost compared to placebo ^[21]. Older men benefit especially from its stress-reduction properties, since cortisol tends to rise with age as testosterone drops.

A 12-week fenugreek study of men around 54.8 years old found better total testosterone (up by 12.2%) and calculated free testosterone (up by 9.5%) ^[20]. These benefits came with improved sexual function—a top concern for aging men ^[5].

Research specifically targeting men over 60 remains limited for both herbs. More age-focused studies would help clarify their benefits.

Adaptogen vs direct booster: key differences

Ashwagandha's role as an adaptogen and fenugreek's position as a direct testosterone booster create several practical differences for users.

Ashwagandha offers more than just testosterone support. Better sleep, less anxiety, and improved stress resilience ^[23] are great ways to get better hormone health while improving life quality. These complete benefits might work better for men who face multiple age-related issues beyond low testosterone.

Fenugreek focuses directly on testosterone metabolism. Its benefits mainly affect hormone-related functions like muscle strength, sex drive, and body composition ^[3]. The herb also helps regulate blood sugar levels ^[3].

Older men should base their choice on personal health goals and what's causing their testosterone decline. Men with stress-related hormone issues might do better with ashwagandha. Those wanting direct testosterone support might prefer fenugreek. Both herbs have earned their spot among natural remedies for male andropause. Their different mechanisms often work well together.

Dosage, Safety, and Standardization

The right dose and safety guidelines are vital considerations when choosing between ashwagandha and fenugreek to boost testosterone. These natural supplements don't have FDA oversight, so you need to know everything about them to make smart choices, especially if you're over 60.

Recommended dosages for each herb

Research shows ashwagandha works best at 300-600mg daily to reduce anxiety ^[9]. For testosterone benefits, you'll need 300-500mg twice daily ^[24]. The type of extract makes a big difference—KSM-66 extract with 5% withanolides works at 600-675mg daily ^[25]. Shoden extract needs just 60-200mg daily because it has more withanolides ^[26].

Most studies show fenugreek seed extract works at 500-600mg daily over 8-12 weeks ^[25]. Tests proving testosterone increases used 500-600mg daily ^[20]. Higher amounts (5-25g) helped with cholesterol and blood sugar ^[27].

Side effect profiles in older adults

Older adults handle both herbs well. Ashwagandha users report mild issues like headaches (8%), muscle aches (4%), nausea (4%), and stomach problems (2%) ^[26]. These usually go away on their own and happen mostly with higher doses.

Fenugreek is also safe, though some people get diarrhea, indigestion, or headaches ^[27]. Anyone with peanut or chickpea allergies should be careful since these plants are related ^[25].

Standardization issues in supplements

Quality control is the biggest problem with both herbs. Neither has clear upper limits ^[28], even though clinical tests show good results. Testosterone supplements often pack too much of certain ingredients—one study found B12 levels at 1,291% of daily needs ^[29].

The FDA doesn't regulate testosterone supplements ^[30], despite all the marketing hype. This means quality varies widely, and only 24.8% of supplement ingredients actually help boost testosterone ^[29].

Interactions with medications

You need to be careful when taking these herbs with prescription drugs. Ashwagandha might cause problems with:

Diabetes medications (blood sugar might drop too low) ^[12]
Blood pressure medications (pressure might drop too much) ^[12]
Thyroid medications (hormone levels might rise) ^[12]
Immunosuppressants and organ transplant drugs ^[31]
Sedatives (might make you too drowsy) ^[12]

Fenugreek has 53 known drug interactions—one moderate and 52 minor ^[32]. It's especially tricky with diabetes medications since it can lower blood sugar further ^[25].

Men taking multiple medications—common after 60—should talk to their doctor before trying either herb. This becomes even more important if you're worried about ashwagandha's effect on your liver or fenugreek's impact on blood sugar.

Cost and Practical Considerations

Alpha X 10-in-1 Complex testosterone booster supplement bottle and box with 3.9-star rating from 82 reviews.

Men over 60 need to think about several practical factors to determine the best natural testosterone herbs. The best value comes from understanding costs, availability, timeframes, and ways to monitor progress.

Price comparison of common extracts

Standard fenugreek extracts are available from £12.49 at Holland & Barrett ^[33]. Premium options like VitaMonk's FenuTrax cost about £22.23 for two months ^[34]. Ashwagandha prices change based on the extract type:

KSM-66 (5% withanolides): Studies use this type most often
Sensoril (higher withaferin A content)
Shoden (35% withanolide glycosides): Works better at lower doses ^[35]

Availability and trusted sources

These herbs are available at health food stores and online retailers. Quality matters most - look for standardized extracts that list their withanolide content (ashwagandha) or saponin percentage (fenugreek). Products with third-party testing certificates are your safest bet.

How long to take for results

Results take time. Ashwagandha users see the most important benefits after 2-3 months of regular use ^[36]. Some studies show testosterone increases within 6 weeks ^[36]. Fenugreek shows measurable changes after about 6 weeks ^[37]. The best approach takes 8-12 weeks followed by a rest period ^[35].

Monitoring testosterone levels at home

Home testing gives you a way to track your progress easily. Finger-prick kits cost around £33.95 and give results in 2-5 days ^[7]. Venous blood tests start at £49.95 ^[7] and give a better explanation of testosterone and related hormones.

Conclusion

Comparing ashwagandha and fenugreek for testosterone support after 60 reveals unique benefits through different mechanisms. Ashwagandha works as an adaptogen that reduces cortisol and creates a hormonal environment where testosterone can thrive. Fenugreek takes a different approach - it blocks enzymes that convert testosterone to other hormones and helps preserve existing testosterone levels.

Your choice between these natural options depends on your health needs. Men who experience stress-related hormone decline might get better results from ashwagandha's all-encompassing approach. It also helps improve sleep quality and reduces anxiety. Those who need direct testosterone metabolism support might find fenugreek more helpful, especially since it helps regulate blood sugar and metabolic health.

Both supplements have good safety profiles. Men on medications should be careful because of possible interactions. Quality plays a big role - you'll get more consistent results from standardized extracts with specific withanolide content (for ashwagandha) or saponin percentage (for fenugreek).

Men who want complete hormone support can combine these herbs with other natural approaches like the Mediterranean diet, vitamin B supplementation, or boron. This strategy often works better than using just one supplement.

Whatever herb you pick, you'll see the best results if you use it regularly for 8-12 weeks. At-home testing helps track your progress and lets you adjust your approach. Testosterone levels naturally drop with age, but these natural remedies for male andropause can help men stay vital and healthy past their sixties.

Key Takeaways

For men over 60 considering natural testosterone support, understanding the distinct mechanisms and benefits of ashwagandha versus fenugreek can guide optimal supplement selection.

• Ashwagandha works indirectly by reducing cortisol levels up to 30%, creating favorable hormonal conditions for 14.7% testosterone increases

• Fenugreek directly preserves testosterone by blocking conversion enzymes, showing 12-46% increases in clinical trials

• Ashwagandha offers broader benefits including improved sleep, reduced anxiety, and stress resilience beyond hormone support

• Fenugreek provides targeted testosterone metabolism support plus valuable blood sugar regulation for metabolic health

• Both herbs require 8-12 weeks of consistent use at clinically-studied doses (300-600mg daily) for optimal results

• Men taking medications should consult healthcare providers due to potential interactions, especially with diabetes and blood pressure drugs

The choice between these natural testosterone boosters depends on individual health goals: ashwagandha for comprehensive stress-related hormone decline, or fenugreek for direct testosterone preservation. Both demonstrate favorable safety profiles and can be effectively monitored through at-home testosterone testing to track progress over time.

FAQs

Q1. Which herb is more effective for boosting testosterone in older men: ashwagandha or fenugreek? Both herbs show promise, but their mechanisms differ. Ashwagandha works indirectly by reducing stress and cortisol levels, potentially leading to a 14.7% increase in testosterone. Fenugreek acts more directly on testosterone metabolism, with studies showing increases of 12-46%. The best choice depends on individual health needs and underlying causes of low testosterone.

Q2. How long does it typically take to see results when using fenugreek for testosterone support? Most studies show measurable results after about 6 weeks of consistent fenugreek supplementation. However, for optimal benefits, it's recommended to use fenugreek for 8-12 weeks before assessing its full effects on testosterone levels.

Q3. Are there any specific benefits of fenugreek for men over 60? Yes, fenugreek can be particularly beneficial for older men. Studies have shown that fenugreek extracts can increase free testosterone levels in men with age-related androgen decline. Additionally, it may help reduce physical symptoms associated with hypogonadism, making it a potentially valuable supplement for men over 60.

Q4. What is the recommended dosage for ashwagandha when used for testosterone support? Clinical studies typically use 300-500mg of ashwagandha extract twice daily for testosterone support. However, the dosage can vary based on the specific extract used. For example, KSM-66 extract (standardized to 5% withanolides) shows effectiveness at 600-675mg daily, while more concentrated extracts may require lower doses.

Q5. Are there any potential side effects or interactions to be aware of when taking these herbs? Both ashwagandha and fenugreek are generally well-tolerated, but they can interact with certain medications. Ashwagandha may interact with diabetes medications, blood pressure medications, and thyroid medications. Fenugreek can affect blood sugar levels and may interact with diabetes medications. It's crucial for men over 60, who are often on multiple medications, to consult with their healthcare provider before starting either supplement.

References

Langue